Fire Island has long been one of New York’s most cherished escapes, offering visitors a refreshing break from the fast-paced energy of the city. With no cars, only ferries and water taxis to get around, the island’s pace slows down in the best possible way. The sound of rolling waves, the scent of salt air, and the sight of untouched dunes make it a place where stress simply doesn’t belong. If you’re looking for the best things to do in Fire Island, you’ll be spoiled for choice. From sun-soaked beaches to buzzing nightlife, from historic landmarks to quiet trails, Fire Island has something for everyone.
Let’s explore everything you need to know to make your Fire Island adventure unforgettable.
How to Get to Fire Island
Unlike many destinations, Fire Island is special because it’s car-free. This makes arriving part of the experience. The main way to reach the island is by ferry. Ferries depart from Bay Shore, Sayville, and Patchogue, and each route connects to different communities such as Ocean Beach, Cherry Grove, and Fire Island Pines. The ferry ride itself takes about 30 minutes and offers a glimpse of the ocean horizon as anticipation builds.
If you prefer flexibility, water taxis run between towns throughout the day, making it easy to hop between communities. Private boats are another option for those who want to dock at one of Fire Island’s marinas.
Pro tip: Check ferry schedules carefully—each town has its own. It’s surprisingly easy to end up on the wrong side of the island if you don’t plan ahead.
Exploring Fire Island Towns & Communities
One of the most unique aspects of Fire Island is the variety of communities you can explore. Each has its own personality, charm, and vibe.
Ocean Beach
Ocean Beach is the unofficial capital of Fire Island. Known for its lively atmosphere, Ocean Beach is packed with shops, restaurants, bars, and art galleries. Families, day-trippers, and young professionals mingle here. Clean beaches, nightlife, and a pedestrian-friendly layout make it a top spot. Just don’t forget—eating on the beach is prohibited to keep it pristine.
Cherry Grove
Cherry Grove is historic and vibrant, often called America’s first gay and lesbian town. With its colorful boardwalks, iconic Ice Palace nightclub, and thriving art scene, it’s a hub for LGBTQ+ culture. Events like the Miss Fire Island contest add to its festive spirit.
Fire Island Pines
Just a short walk from Cherry Grove, The Pines is another LGBTQ+ haven. Known for its high-energy “tea dances,” glamorous architecture, and upscale restaurants, this community blends natural beauty with cultural vibrancy. The annual “Invasion of the Pines,” where drag queens arrive by ferry, is one of Fire Island’s most famous events.
Kismet
If you’re looking for a more laid-back atmosphere, head to Kismet. It’s family-friendly, with a marina, playground, and easy access to Robert Moses State Park and the Fire Island Lighthouse. Kismet has a mellow, Margaritaville-like charm.
Ocean Bay Park
Originally built for New York police and firefighters, Ocean Bay Park has evolved into a lively mix of families, professionals, and artists. With quirky houses, beachside hangouts, and plenty of live music, this town delivers both relaxation and fun.
Fair Harbor
In Fair Harbor, you’ll often see barefoot visitors strolling the boardwalks. It’s home to charming shops, great dining, and the popular Pine Walk Crafts Fair each July. The atmosphere is carefree, perfect for those seeking simplicity with a touch of community spirit.
Davis Park
For those craving solitude, Davis Park is the perfect destination. It’s quieter and more secluded, making it an ideal choice for weekend retreats away from the bustle of other towns.
Top Attractions & Landmarks
Beyond its beaches and nightlife, Fire Island has landmarks worth exploring.
Fire Island Lighthouse
Standing proudly near Robert Moses State Park, the Fire Island Lighthouse is one of the island’s most recognizable icons. Visitors can climb to the top for panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean and Long Island. It’s also steeped in maritime history, dating back to the 19th century.
Sunken Forest
The Sunken Forest is a natural wonder. This rare maritime forest, tucked behind sand dunes, feels like stepping into another world. Wooden boardwalks make it easy to wander among the trees, spot wildlife, and enjoy the serene atmosphere.
Robert Moses State Park
At the western edge of Fire Island lies Robert Moses State Park, perfect for families. With five miles of sandy beach, picnic areas, and fishing spots, it’s a versatile destination for outdoor fun.
Best Beaches on Fire Island
No list of things to do in Fire Island would be complete without highlighting its beaches. Stretching for 30 miles, they’re among the most beautiful in the United States.
- Ocean Beach – A lively hub with plenty of nearby shops and restaurants.
- Fire Island Pines Beach – Known for its beauty and LGBTQ+ social scene.
- Cedar Beach – Quiet and secluded, perfect for peaceful escapes.
- Watch Hill – Remote and ideal for nature lovers.
Outdoor Activities
Fire Island isn’t just about lounging on the sand—though that’s always a good option. The island is packed with outdoor adventures.
- Swimming and surfing – The Atlantic waves offer fun for swimmers and surfers alike.
- Hiking – Explore trails like the Sunken Forest or walk between towns along the beach.
- Boating and kayaking – Marinas and calm bays make water sports accessible.
- Fishing – Both surf fishing and charter fishing trips are popular.
- Camping – While most of the island doesn’t allow camping, Watch Hill offers campgrounds for those who want to sleep under the stars.
Dining & Nightlife
Food and nightlife are at the heart of the Fire Island experience.
Seafood is king here—lobster, clams, mussels, and oysters fill many menus. Restaurants like The Hideaway in Ocean Beach and Canes in Ocean Bay Park are favorites. For casual bites, burgers, sandwiches, and ice cream shops are easy to find.
Nightlife is legendary in places like Cherry Grove and The Pines, where bars, drag shows, and late-night dancing keep the energy high. The Pines’ tea dances are iconic, while Cherry Grove’s Ice Palace remains a staple of LGBTQ+ nightlife.
Travel Tips for Visiting Fire Island
- Best time to visit: Summer (June to September) is peak season, but late spring and early fall offer fewer crowds.
- Getting around: Walking, biking, and water taxis are the main options. Cars aren’t allowed in most areas.
- Accommodations: From cozy bed-and-breakfasts to upscale rentals, there’s something for every budget—though summer pricing is steep. Book early!
- Pack smart: Bring essentials from the mainland. Prices on Fire Island are higher, and options can be limited.
- Stay safe: Watch for ticks in wooded areas, and remember that public drinking is tolerated on beaches but not in towns like Ocean Beach.
Conclusion
From its lively LGBTQ+ hubs to tranquil family-friendly villages, from historic lighthouses to endless stretches of sandy beaches, Fire Island is a destination with many sides. Whether you’re chasing nightlife, nature, or nostalgia, you’ll find it here. The best things to do in Fire Island aren’t just about activities—they’re about embracing the island’s slower pace, soaking up its natural beauty, and enjoying its unique communities.
If you’re ready to trade car horns for ocean waves and skyscrapers for sand dunes, Fire Island awaits.
